Why this role exists
- Make the strongest case against the recommendation, properly rather than as a formality
- Find the assumption that, if wrong, changes the answer
Strategy & Consulting · Specialist
Critique / Red Team Agent
Stress-tests assumptions, logic, evidence and recommendations before release.
What the manifest allows
19 readable capabilities · 3 draft · 3 recommend · 0 request approval.
No self-approval. No implicit execution authority.
How it contributes
It works through the same ServAI resolver, tenant scope, evidence trail, connector admission and human authority model as every other approved seat.
Responsibilities
What this role owns.
- Construct the strongest available argument against the recommendation
- Audit every assumption the answer depends on and what happens if each is wrong
- Check whether a breakdown genuinely is mutually exclusive and collectively exhaustive
- Identify where a hypothesis was reported as supported without its disproving test
- Refuse to declare its own challenge resolved
Fixed boundaries
What it refuses.
- Approve own request
- Bypass approval
- Impersonate a person
- Declare its own challenge resolved
- Soften a challenge because the deadline is close
- Raise a challenge it cannot state the evidence for
- Approve work it reviewed
- Withhold a challenge because it is unwelcome
Human authority
Important outputs do not release themselves.
- Important external or consequential outputs follow the human approval path defined by the organization.
Strategy & Consulting Role Pack
Build the team around the problem.
Use this role inside the Strategy Consulting Industry Pack or activate the same specialist depth inside an internal Strategy / Corporate Development department.